Top of the Lake "Searchers Search" Review | Off the Beaten Path
Man, time in the age of the quarantine sure seems to have a funny way of slipping by, especially when we’re stuck inside. Luckily for us, Top of the Lake is a (so far) well-crafted show that gives us a glimpse of the outside world in all its complicated glory. More than scenic vistas though, Searchers Search gives us a clue as to how to interact with each other once we’re able to by giving us an example of how not to interact with each other.
The Episode Summary
Searchers Search is largely a Robin episode, so it comes as no surprise that she drives the narrative. For her, she starts the episode by walking out into the same lake Tui did a few days previously. From there she begins the job of finding Tui. She first holds a meeting with the local officers that goes incredibly poorly. Later she organizes (or co-organizes with the town?) a search that was almost immediately doomed to failure due to the sheer scope involved mixed with the dismissiveness of just about everyone. She even checks out a potential suspect aka the local registered pedophile almost on a whim and that gets, shall we say, mixed results at best. Lastly, she checks out both the Paradise camp and the Mitcham estate.
Along the way, Robin starts to connect (or is it technically reconnect even though they largely don’t remember her?) with the folks of Laketop. Between sexist conversations at bars and little progress as work, she does manage to connect with two people. There’s Detective Parker, her de facto partner in the case, and the only one who acknowledges her work on the case as it drags on. There’s also Johnno, her highschool boyfriend who seems to be making a run to dethrone her fiance as the chief love interest (which she seems to almost welcome) despite his seeming indifference. Really the only people Robin doesn’t reconnect with is her family, most prominently her mother, due to being distracted by the case.
Elsewhere in the narrative, there’s Bunny, a resident of the Paradise commune. If you haven’t watched Searchers Search yet, she was the Paradiser with the husband she can’t let go of emotionally that I mentioned in my review of Paradise Sold. First, she goes to a bar to, put it rather mildly, reassert herself sexually without forming any attachments. Later, her ex-husband and her daughter show up at Paradise (by helicopter no less). After an angry confrontation, the ex-husband leaves Bunny and their daughter at the compound.
My Thoughts
So, watching Searchers Search, one thing kept coming to mind: there’s a surprising lack of empathy in this show. Over two separate rewatches, I kept thinking the episode was telling us all about love, but that felt kinda empty to me. It wasn’t until my second rewatch earlier that it hit me; if Searchers Search is telling us anything, it’s that love needs empathy to function.
I ask you, consider this from a cursory point across the whole episode, especially on the investigative side. Throughout the episode, most of the townsfolk don’t seem to be all that concerned that Tui went missing. On the one hand, people like Matt are wholly unconcerned with the whole ordeal; they think she’s just hiding in the local wilderness till she’s ready to come back. On the other hand, people like the officers assigned to her case are equally unconcerned but in a much more morbid sense; they think she’s already dead, so a search is thus pointless.
But you know what, that’s not even what struck me most about the whole situation. That would be that no one (barring Robin) is all that concerned with why Tui ran away. I mean, a pregnant 12-year-old on the lamb has to have her reasons, yet no one is concerned with asking why she might do something so drastic. At most, they just concern themselves with the external reality of the situation; she’s gone, so a cursory search of the countryside needs to be done if only for appearances. The fact that no one, even those who claim to be concerned with her wellbeing (again, barring Robin), can muster up that little bit of empathy is just something else to me.
But that’s just a macroscopic view of the episode theme. There are a couple of microscopic scale scenes I can focus on that help establish this theme of empathy deficiency. There’s Bunny’s rather cold method of reattaining sexual independence. Sure, while it’s well-meaning on her part it is, to me, the wrong approach to solving her predicament. Namely, it looks more like a harmful overcorrection than legitimate healing and connection.
There’s also the speech Zanic gives to Robin about how the love of equals is a sham when talking about the most beautiful boy in the world. Sure, it’s the most passionate declaration of love for another human being given, but it’s twisted and corrupted at the core. I mean, how can you empathize with someone if you don’t consider them an equal and profess you know them better than they know themselves?
There’s one in particular though I want to touch upon, and it may surprise you at this point. It’s a scene near the beginning of the episode, where Robin walks out into the same lake Tui walked into. In an episode that displays a citizenry lacking empathy for one of their own, this one moment is like an oasis to me. It just hammers home what I saw in Paradise Sold; Robin, by empathizing with the one girl no one seems all that concerned about, proves she is the only person suited for this rather grizzly job.
But enough about the theme. Jane Campion isn’t just concerned with the thematic content of Searchers Search. Plus, thematic depth alone doesn’t make something good. So then, what else does Searchers Search have going for it?
If there’s anything else that struck me about Searchers Search, it’s that if you’re looking for a fast-paced mystery with lots of set pieces ala True Detective, you’re probably checking out at this point. Which is fair, cause an investigative speedrun Top of the Lake is not. Instead, Campion is content to take her time and meander through the story, getting picturesque looks at the landscape (and good lord is it picturesque) as much as the citizens of Laketop.
I mean, besides some foreshadowing (which I’ll get to in a minute) and character arc growth, not much of consequence has happened so far. Sure, this will rub some people the wrong way, but to me at least this isn’t much of an issue. After seeing Utopia, a much more adrenaline-fueled show, waste potential and runtime on certain story elements (and that’s on top of each season only lasting 6 episodes), I’m content to watch Top of the Lake take its time and breath.
Going back to the theme for a minute, Campion does more with the theme than just making a point wantonly. Namely, she uses the theme in other to keep Robin from making any headway. I mean, the empathic apathy of the town is a better roadblock on a plot and existential level than any simple dead ends and endless red herrings that plague similar shows (looking at you The Killing).
Another thing Searchers Search does to build on Paradise Sold is establishing (rather welcome) hints about what’s to come. On a more obvious note, there’s something shady going on at the Mitcham estate, what with a gaggle of ladies piling out his bathroom during the execution of a search warrant and the light coming out of the shower drain.
But also, shit is weird with Detective Parker. I mean, he meets with Matt in the middle of the lake to warn Matt about the warrant and make some kind of payment, and he volunteers to check out the shed unprompted. On a more low-key note, he shares some commonalities with Zanic. They both run local operations dedicated to helping problematic youth (Zanic with dancing, Parker with the cafe). This is also after he points out in the police briefing that pedophiles seek out positions of authority and that Zanic is the only registered pedophile in the town. So again, for all his bonding with Robin, there’s something off about Parker. I mean, this could all be a red herring, but I’d keep an eye on him if I were you.
For another bit of foreshadowing, the fact that Robin is the only person seemingly able to empathize and relate to Tui’s plight says something deeper about her character. Sure, it could be a byproduct of the job; being a detective who specializes in sexual assault in a larger city would cause you to become more aware of the victim’s plight. But there’s more there in my mind. Knowing Robin has a dark past in Laketop as a child brings up the idea that Robin herself experienced a similar kind of trauma. It could be Campion’s way of demonstrating why the people of Laketop can’t seem to understand Tui’s plight; they just don’t understand because they haven’t been there themselves. I’m betting all of these foreshadowing bits are coming to the forefront, but the stuff about Robin most of all.
If I have any real complaints about Searchers Search, it would have to be that the conflict between the Paradise commune and the Mitcham clan is largely put on the back burner. While Bunny’s whole story helps carry the theme of the episode and unveil certain aspects of GJ’s instructions and nihilistic outlook, not a whole lot else was done. But luckily, that’s mostly a small bit, about 10 minutes worth in the first half of the episode.
In Conclusion
So after the melancholic and introspective set-up of Paradise Sold, where does Jane Campion take us with Searchers Search? Is it an adrenaline-fueled rollercoaster ala Utopia? Is it just more of the same? If you’ve been watching Top of the Lake along with me, then you know it’s a resounding “more of the same”. But you know what, it’s more than just the same. It’s a dark look at how we relate and empathize with members of our community, and what happens when that empathy is sorely lacking. Is it flawless? No. Is it worth your while? I’d say yes.
Final Recommendation: Recommend